BREAKING: The India-Pakistan cricket rivalry exploded into fresh controversy on September 28, 2025, as India defeated Pakistan in the Asia Cup final, only for Indian players to refuse handshakes with their Pakistani counterparts. This latest incident amplifies former England captain Michael Atherton’s stark warning: cricket is now a ‘proxy for broader tensions and propaganda,’ far beyond the pitch.
Key Takeaways
- India holds a dominant 15-1 record against Pakistan in ICC World Cup matches.
- Indian players notably refused handshakes after winning the 2025 Asia Cup final.
- Bilateral cricket series between the nations have been frozen since 2013 due to political tensions.
- The India-Pakistan fixture drives a significant portion of the ICC’s $3 billion broadcast rights.
- Indian captain Suryakumar Yadav questioned if the lopsided results still constitute a ‘rivalry.’
- India’s team also refused to accept the 2025 Asia Cup trophy from Pakistan’s Interior Minister.
You might also like
Asia Cup Shocker: India Refuses Trophy, Stuns Cricket World
Shock: Cricket’s Biggest Rivalry Erupts in Geopolitical Storm
Dubai’s Historic Asia Cup Final: Jail Threats & 7 Lakh Fines!
Asia Cup Snub: India’s Defiant Victory!
Asia Cup Shocker: Trophy ‘Ran Away’ – Cricket Chaos!
India’s Asia Cup Triumph: Bold Stand, Pakistan Stunned!
SKY’s Stand: India Wins Asia Cup 2025!
The deeply rooted animosity between the two nations, stemming from historical partitions and ongoing geopolitical conflicts, transforms every match into a high-stakes affair. What was once seen as a potential avenue for “cricket diplomacy” has increasingly become a reflection—and amplifier—of strained political relations.
Match Turning Points & Controversies
India’s dominance over Pakistan in ICC tournaments is stark. They have won 15 out of 16 encounters across ODI and T20 World Cups, including an unbeaten 8-0 record in 50-over World Cups. In T20 World Cups, India leads 7-1, having won the inaugural edition in 2007 against Pakistan in the final. Pakistan’s sole T20 World Cup victory against India was in 2021.
The 2025 Asia Cup final on September 28, 2025, saw India defeat Pakistan by 5 wickets. This followed an earlier decisive victory in the 2025 ICC Champions Trophy on February 23, 2025, where India won by 6 wickets, with Virat Kohli scoring his 51st ODI century. The post-match refusal by Indian players to shake hands, mirroring a similar incident with the women’s teams’ captains (Harmanpreet Kaur and Fatima Sana), underscored the palpable tension. Adding to the drama, the Indian team declined to accept the Asia Cup trophy from Pakistan’s Interior Minister and ACC chairman, Mohsin Naqvi.
Get the Latest Updates
Be part of our sports community for daily news, expert analysis, and insider info.
Expert Analysis
Former England captain Michael Atherton articulated the growing concern, stating, “If cricket was once the vehicle for diplomacy, it is now, clearly, a proxy for broader tensions and for propaganda.” He highlighted the immense commercial draw of the fixture, noting that broadcast rights for ICC tournaments are worth approximately $3 billion for the 2023-27 cycle, with India-Pakistan matches being a primary driver due to their scarcity and economic power.
Atherton also questioned the ethics of scheduling, arguing, “There is little justification… for a serious sport to arrange tournament fixtures to suit its economic needs.” Cricket analyst Krishna Tunga expressed skepticism about Pakistan’s ability to provide a safe environment for international cricket, citing past incidents. Sports journalist Chirayu J reinforced the economic imperative, stating, “the ICC cannot conduct major tournaments without India and Pakistan participating.”
Social Media Storm
Every India-Pakistan encounter ignites a colossal social media storm, and the 2025 Asia Cup was no exception. The hand-shake controversy and the trophy refusal swiftly became viral flashpoints, dominating trending topics across platforms. Fans from both sides engaged in heated debates, fueling emotional contagion and further polarizing opinions. Quotes from players like Suryakumar Yadav, who questioned if it could still be called a “rivalry” given India’s consistent dominance, were widely shared and discussed, reflecting the intense scrutiny and fan investment in every aspect of this iconic clash.
Unbiased View: The Shifting Sands of a Sporting Saga
Analysis reveals that the India-Pakistan cricket rivalry has profoundly evolved from a diplomatic overture to a complex reflection of geopolitical and commercial realities. Experts note that while the contests remain a massive spectacle, attracting unparalleled viewership, the increasing political baggage and commercial exploitation risk overshadowing the sport’s integrity. According to verified sources, the ICC faces a significant dilemma in balancing financial imperatives with maintaining the spirit of the game, particularly when fixture scheduling transparency is called into question. This unique dynamic highlights the enduring power of sport to reflect, and at times exacerbate, real-world tensions.
Tournament Impact & Future Implications
The political tensions have led to a complete freeze in bilateral cricket series between India and Pakistan since 2007 (Tests) and 2013 (white-ball matches). This freeze directly impacts ICC tournament scheduling. India’s recent ban on its men’s team participating in the upcoming 2025 Champions Trophy hosted in Pakistan, citing security concerns, has initiated discussions about relocating the tournament to neutral venues. This ongoing saga underscores the immense commercial pressure on the Asian Cricket Council (ACC) and the ICC to ensure these high-revenue generating matches occur, often leading to controversies surrounding their fixture arrangement, as highlighted by Atherton’s call for transparency in tournament draws.
The future of India-Pakistan cricket remains uncertain, caught between national pride, geopolitical strife, and undeniable commercial appeal. What’s next for ICC in navigating this delicate balance?